In a normal pregnancy, the egg will be fertilized in the fallopian tube within 48 hours of intercourse; this fertilized ovum is known as the zygote and begins to cellular division process quickly Etherington, Just because abortion is morally impermissible, it does not mean that society will deem you a bad person for getting an abortion under extreme circumstances.
However, it does not change the fact that you are denying a being of a valuable future and for that reason I would say it is morally impermissible. With that established the question remains, is it moral to be unplugged or get an abortion?
Not allowing a being the potential for a future like ours i. But why is a sharp line necessary? Unfortunately, this is true and for that reason it is impossible to address each and every possible scenario.
In order for anyone to prevent a strong case for any argument, it is very important to address potential counterarguments. More essays like this: In fact, if I were put into such a situation, I too would request to be unplugged from the violinist because I was unwillingly taken advantage of and do no want to have to deal with the issue.
Marquis then connects this idea with abortion by saying that aborting a fetus is depriving a being of a valuable future. At the end of the day, you denied a person the ability to pursue the future they desire.
This counterargument poses a very realistic concern but it is one I believe to be dismissible. A newly fertilized ovum, a newly implanted clump of cells, is no more a person that an acorn is an oak tree"p. For instance, Harrison believes that by the time a fetus becomes a neonate, the argument over permissibility is over and the jury is in.
In this regard, Hursthouse emphasizes that, "The morality of abortion is commonly discussed in relation to just two considerations: The Moral Debate about Abortion Although the debate over abortion tends to become emotionally charged, there are some fundamental issues involved that can be is abortion morally permissible essay writer from a strictly pragmatic perspective to help determine if abortion is ever morally permissible.
Thomson presents a clear but unfortunate reality that is abortion morally permissible essay writer deals with much to often. For example, Harrison writes that, "My own view is that infanticide is more morally dubious than late-stage abortion, precisely because the life of the neonate can be differentiated from the mother in a way not possible before birth" p.
To this end, this paper provides a review of the peer-reviewed and scholarly literature to determine what the experts have to say about the moral debate over abortion in general and at what point personhood is achieved in particular.
Therefore, the very first physical manifestation of a sexual union is a zygote, followed by an embryo, fetus and then a fully formed human being; however, there remain stark differences of opinion concerning the exact developmental point at which the cells assume sufficient qualities to be deemed actual human beings Joyce, Marquis reasons this by explaining what is wrong with killing is that you are depriving someone of a future.
In this regard, Hursehouse argues that, "One might say that this issue is not in the province of any moral theory; it is a metaphysical question, and an extremely difficult one at that"p. Indeed, even if they have no such right, such a law might be, as things stand at the moment, unjust, or impractical, or inhumane"p.
Some authorities argue that by the third trimester, a fetus has developed to the point where it has assumed those qualities that define a person.
For example, Joyce notes that, "Accordingly, if one is a developmentalist and argues that the fetus does not become a person until some later stage of its development one could conclude that it only becomes wrong to kill it after that stage has been reached"p.
You wake up in the morning and find yourself back to back in bed with an unconscious violinist. There is no clear-cut answer as to whether or not abortion should be allowed and because of that the government should not downright illegalize abortion.
Moreover, there are the other issues that impact the desirability of a given pregnancy such as instances of rape or incest, acts that are frequently cited by abortion proponents as being among the most important reasons for keeping the practice legal. These issues include most especially the precise point at which a fertilized human embryo can be regarded as a "human being" and therefore protected by the laws of the land as well as moral proscriptions against abortion.
This nebulous line in the permissibility sand has been the source of much of the controversy concerning the moral permissibility of abortion, making its further examination timely and relevant today. As I discussed, in an example of a rape case abortion is still immoral because you are depriving a being of a future like ours, yet society will not necessarily scold you for it.
On the other hand, though, proponents of abortion argue that a newly fertilized zygote requires time to develop and assume the qualities that define a real human being. For that reason, abortion is a specifically tricky topic to discuss.
Essentially, Marquis offers one explanation as to why killing could be immoral while clarifying that it could be one of many reasons for killing to be immoral. At first thought, many people would deem the situation unfair and immediately request an abortion.
Importantly, he notes that this does not only apply to humans but rather to all species, or anything with a future of value for that matter. If I present the argument that abortion is morally wrong because it denies the potential future of a being, then it would be fair to say that not allowing an abortion denies the autonomy of a being to pursue the future they desire.
It is not only immoral, but also unfair, to deny a being of a future in an attempt to correct a challenge to your own. In conclusion, abortion is morally impermissible in almost all cases but that does not necessarily mean that abortion is frowned upon in all cases.
In this regard, Hursthouse reports that, "Many women who have borne children contrast their later pregnancies with their first successful one, saying that in the later ones they were conscious of a new life growing in them from very early on"p. The defining issue, then, appears to concern the exact point in time at which the fetus assumes sufficient human qualities to counter the rights of the mother if this argument can be made at all.
Review and Discussion Although arguments against abortion vary in scope, intensity and reasons, the majority of opposition is related to the conceptualization of a fetus as a human being from the very start.ABORTION: IS IT MORALLY WRONG?
INTRODUCTION Abortion is the intentional termination of a pregnancy after conception. It allows women to put an end to their pregnancies, but involves killing the undeveloped embryo or fetus. For this reason, it is a very controversial subject. Abortion should not be an optional procedure for careless mothers.
It should not be available to solve an inconvenience of a heartless person. There are only two exceptions to abortion being morally permissible; imminent death of the mother, and rape. Essay about Is Abortion Morally Permissible or Not?
Words | 6 Pages the morality of abortion with specific reference to the writings of Don Marquis, Judith.
Unlike Marquis, I believe abortion is not impermissible yet not always permissible either. Upon thorough inspection, I have found some flaws in Marquis' argument.
Marquis tries to argue that "personhood" is not the moral category in question with regards to the moral permissibility of abortion. Therefore, abortion is permissible since it is a choice, but the decision should be based on circumstances.
However, in order to not form any confusion, abortion is not considered murder. A murderer poses risks to society while the doctor conducting the abortion poses no risks.
The Argument of Abortion - Philosophy Essay The Argument of Abortion - Philosophy Essay In On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion, Mary Anne Warren discusses a few arguments against abortion, namely bringing into play whether the fetus is actually a person, or “not a .Download